IT'S the ned capital of Scotland, has one of the highest murder rates in Europe, and is one of the worst places in the UK for knife crime.
We've all heard the shock-horror claims about Glasgow. And despite the city's remarkable regeneration in recent years, frightening crime levels are a bleak reminder that the No Mean City reputation of last century has yet to be shaken off.
In the run-up to the Holyrood elections, the politicians know they can't afford to sweep under the carpet the culture of violence, drugs and yob behaviour which blights Scotland's biggest city. The statistics are certainly frightening - regardless of how the numbers are massaged or spun. What the parties say. . .
LABOUR Give police powers to issue "instant Asbos" and impose curfews without having to go through courts. Community police team in every area, with a named senior officer to "report" to the community they serve. Double the number of community wardens to more than 1000 and name and shame people who cause crime. Consider whether further measures are needed to tackle the booze and blade culture, and support the Violence Reduction Unit in tackling root causes of violence. SNP Recruit 1000 more police and encourage use in policing communities. Seek Scottish solutions on air guns by opening negotiations with Westminster for Scotland to make its own firearms legislation. Treat vandalism as crime, not anti-social behaviour. Asbos should not be used when criminal charges are more appropriate. Get tough on off-licence bosses who sell to under-18s, with loss of licences for any caught. Demand judges impose sentences according to guidelines or they must state on record why not. LIBDEMS Recruit 1000 extra community police officers, and provide funding for two extra community officers in each council ward. Improve links between residents and community officers. Do more to get to the root of offending behaviour and tackle Scotland's drug and alcohol culture. Crack down on knife crime with seven-year maximum combined custody and community sentences for possession of blades. Tougher community sentences to make offenders work to repay their crimes and cut reoffending. CONSERVATIVE Put victims first and ensure they are regularly briefed on developments in their cases. Hire 1500 more police officers in communities. Improve links between residents and community officers. Publish regular crime statistics, community by community. Zero tolerance towards vandalism, graffiti and anti-social behaviour. No bail for alleged murderers, rapists and violent criminals while they await trial. GREENS More emphasis on community policing; corporate homicide legislation that places duties on individual directors; people convicted of environmental crimes to pay for restoration of damage. SSP Zero tolerance for violence against women, children and vulnerable people; give non-custodial sentences to offenders who are not a danger to public to reduce prison population. SOLIDARITY Ban sale and use of air rifles, pistols and pellet guns except in a registered gun club or by registered pest control officer; encourage restorative justice sentencing, which will see offenders do work in the community.
As revealed by the Evening Times last year, every community in Glasgow is affected by the most serious crimes such as rape, serious assault and attempted murder.
Surgeons operate on victims of facial slash wounds on average every six hours in the city, where the decades-old knife and gang cultures still show no sign of letting up.
Coupled with the daily menaces of anti-social behaviour, vandalism, and intimidation from street-corner neds and drunks, the catalogue of problems means virtually every resident has a story to tell about the darker side of Glasgow.
However the clamour to reclaim the streets has never been greater, and the big four parties have been tripping over each other during the election campaign to tell the electorate about how they're going to increase the policing of communities by putting more officers on the streets, or upping the numbers of community wardens.
The promise of more beat cops is undoubtedly a vote winner, but according to crime experts and senior officers, it's only a short-term fix.
In the age of intelligence-led policing, forces like to deploy officers to hotspots rather than across the board, and according to Mike Nellis, Professor of Criminal and Community Justice at Strathclyde University, long-term solutions are needed.
The academic says Scotland should look more at the use of tools such as parenting orders - which oblige mums and dads to control trouble kids - and Asbos, which can threaten jail unless conditions are met, and have been sparsely used here compared with England and Wales.
Prof Nellis said: "I can understand why Scotland would be wary about the Asbo agenda, looking at what's happened in England and Wales, where it's out of control in parts - there's Asbo mania, with the orders given out for anything and everything.
"But there is a middle ground about dealing with anti-social behaviour, and we shouldn't necessarily be afraid of using Asbos."
Prof Nellis points to the popularity of dispersal orders which, before Christmas, gave police the power to break up groups under Asbo laws in Dennistoun and Knightswood.
He said tools such as these should be coupled with social work-led policies suggested by Detective Chief Superintendent John Carnochan, whose Scotland-wide Violence Reduction Unit is looking at how "early years initiatives" can reach children from high-risk backgrounds before they fall into lives of violence.
Prof Nellis said: "John Carnochan said recently that he would rather have extra health visitors than police officers. That was a brave statement.
"But however much the politicians tell you otherwise there's too much deprivation, too much destitution, to end the culture of violence in Scotland or make any serious impact in just a few years. It's a question of generational change."
Last year's Executive-backed knife amnesty, which led to 12,500 weapons being handed in across Scotland, was likewise criticised as a short-term fix - even a gimmick - after it emerged last month that it appeared to have had little effect on knife-related crime.
But Prof Nellis said politicians often couldn't win.
"You're damned if you do and damned if you don't. You have to be seen to be doing something - that's politics.
"I think the amnesty was worthwhile as a symbolic gesture, to send out the message that knife-carrying won't be tolerated. There were also more than 12,000 weapons taken off the streets, and if it saves one life, then for me it's worth it."
As for the youth disorder being worse now than in years past, Prof Nellis said the matter was often exaggerated.
"The drugs problem has made the problem of youth crime worse in the past 25 years, indisputably.
"But in all other respects, there's always been serious problems with youth crime, and always people claiming things weren't as bad when I was young'. While drugs have not always been as widespread, there has always been alcohol, for example.
"As long as we have serious deprivation we are always going to have violent crime.
"There can be more police officers, more CCTV, more detections, but you won't take away the incentive to commit crime for those who feel they have no stake in society."
Prof Nellis said Glasgow had done "remarkably well" to reinvent itself in recent years as a booming tourist destination, helped by the City of Culture status and the Scotland with Style campaign.
He said: "It's incredibly important to have a positive image, but the underlying problems of deprivation and crime remain, and rebranding the city is not going to address the situation.
"Glasgow still has one of the worst murder rates for any city of its size in Europe, and we need to look at the long-term solutions. Until then it's going to be difficult to shake off the No Mean City reputation." Your views RONNIE GREEN, 48, City Centre, tutor I do not think there is more that can be done. Putting officers on the streets doesn't really change anything, I don't think that would make a difference. They should educate young people about crime. BRIAN GILLIGAN, 47, Maryhill, unemployed I've just been a victim - a crowd of young thugs smashed my windows - and I'd like GHA to be able to evict the kids' parents. Concentrate on youth crime and adult crime will go down in a few years. CATHERINE WIGHT, 67, retired, Helensburgh I think everybody worries about crime. It's everywhere. The sort of things that happen in Helensburgh are drink and drug related and I think they should do something about those issues. JIM MacNAB, 60, Hamilton, cashier I have not been a victim of crime, touch wood. Up our way they are actually getting more police on the streets, which is what they should be doing, I'd imagine in other areas gangs are a problem. Stats file Surveys show just one in three victims of violent crime report the incidents to police, meaning two in three incidents do not appear in official figures. Strathclyde Police reported a decrease in the number of people carrying blades directly after last year's knife amnesty. However, the figures have returned to previous levels. There were 222 blade-carrying incidents in February, against 223 in February 2006. Nearly 70,000 incidents considered low-level crimes - such as vandalism, breach of the peace, petty assault, urinating in the street and boozing in public places - were committed in Glasgow in 2005/06. Three private properties in Glasgow have been closed by the courts under anti-social behaviour laws since 2004. The closures were for three months and extended to six. Asbo laws have also given police the powers for the two dispersal orders made so far in Glasgow, in Dennistoun and Knightswood. The move was in response to troublemaking youths and gangs. The orders meant police could split up groups of youths.
Share