Woman cleared of causing death of biker on Loch Lomond road

Andrew Jowett died two days after the collision on June 13, 2023 <i>(Image: Police Scotland)</i>
Andrew Jowett died two days after the collision on June 13, 2023 (Image: Police Scotland)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

A woman has been cleared of causing the death of a motorcyclist next to Loch Lomond.

Sarah Landt was found not guilty by a unanimous verdict after a jury trial at Dumbarton Sheriff Court last week.

The 36-year-old had been accused of careless driving by failing to react to the sound of an approaching motorbike, failing to observe it and failing to give way to other motorists.

Andrew Jowett, 37, of Paisley, died two days after he collided in June 2023 with the back of the Skoda Scala driven by Mrs Landt at the northern entrance to Luss on the A82.

Andrew Jowett (Image: Police Scotland)

During the trial, two other motorcyclists with Mr Jowett said they had been going above the speed limit on the 60mph trunk road.

David Leckie, immediately behind Mr Jowett, said he tried to keep his speed when passing below 100mph.


READ MORE:

Motorcyclist in fatal A82 crash had just seconds to react before collision
Driver accused of causing death of motorcyclist heard engine a second before crash


Defence analysis of the crash suggested the victim was driving at 91-95mph when the collision happened.

A police expert said he thought that figure was too high, but agreed Mr Jowett was above the speed limit.

His analysis found the motorbike's engine could be heard on dashcam footage one second before Mrs Landt pulled out from the give way line to head north from Luss.

And a report for the defence found Mr Jowett had 2.2 seconds to try to avoid the collision at 6.41pm on June 13, 2023.

He was thrown 48 metres beyond the vehicles and died in hospital two days later.

Defence advocate Andrew Crosbie KC said in a submission outwith the jury last week that the prosecution's first witness was Mrs Landt's husband. He said he looked south from the junction and did not see Mr Jowett approaching when he said "clear".


READ MORE:

More: Motorbike rider tells trial he tried to keep below 100mph before fatal crash
More: Husband gives evidence in trial of wife accused of causing motorcyclist's death


"Both carried out observations," he said. "There is no evidence Mrs Landt failed to carry out observations.

"There's no evidence about what reaction time might be expected to be, what she is supposed to have done with her body and when.

"And we have seen from dashcam footage the car is fully established in the northbound lane and accelerating."

Mr Crosbie, watched by the family of Mr Jowett who attended the full trial, said he was not making a "character judgement", but noted that witnesses said all three motorbikes were going above the speed limit.

"There is a clear alternative explanation for the collision," he said, "borne out by where the collision took place.

"And there is evidence, from a number of witnesses, in very strong terms, about the speeds of the motorbikes and coming out of nowhere.

"There is a real deficiency in the crown case as to what Mrs Landt is meant to have done wrong here."

Sheriff Maxwell Hendry allowed the trial to continue after that submission.

The jury of 13 found Mrs Landt, of Edinburgh, not guilty on February 2.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos