After World War II, Glasgow continued to debate how to fix its long-standing issues around the housing and health of its citizens.
Two major reports were drawn up with very different ideas about how to resolve the city’s problems.
In this week's column from Glasgow City Archives, senior archivist Dr Irene O'Brien looks into how decisions made in the 1940s and 50s changed Glasgow (and East Kilbride) forever.
The Bruce Plan, 1945, Glasgow’s first and highly controversial planning report, was drawn up by Robert Bruce, Master of Works and City Engineer, to transform Glasgow into a “healthy and beautiful city.”
The Bruce Plan proposed some dramatic changes for Glasgow (Image: Glasgow City Archives)
This sounds great until you realised that it proposed to demolish much of the historic city centre, including many of its iconic buildings.
Issued a year later was the Clyde Valley Regional Plan, which was prepared by the Clyde Valley Regional Planning Committee, established by Thomas Johnston, Secretary State for Scotland.
At its core was the idea that Glasgow’s problems with housing could be solved by reducing the population of the city and building carefully planned new towns.
We hold both plans in Glasgow City Archives at the Mitchell Library.
The planners had other ideas for these areas, including roads, recreational space, and green belt industry - but the housing department was following its own urgent programme and seemed impatient with the grander vision of the planners.
By the end of 1946, Glasgow’s policy changed, accepting the core premise of the Bruce Plan that the city could be redesigned to accommodate all the existing population within the city’s existing boundaries.
A photo of one of East Kilbride's first housing developments (Image: Glasgow City Archives)
This brought the question of overspill of population and the decanting of industry to satellite or new towns into the equation. The city tried (unsuccessfully) to block the government's plans for the first new town at East Kilbride.
Notwithstanding Glasgow’s objection, the East Kilbride Development Corporation planned the new town to accommodate 45,000 to 50,000 people, with opportunities for wide-ranging employment for all its inhabitants. It was also to include essential services and amenities such as schools, shops, churches, places of entertainment, parks and playing fields.
Meanwhile, Glasgow Corporation changed its mind on the best way forward based on the Glasgow’s Needs report by the City Architect and Planning Officer.
This highlighted that only 40,000 houses of the 100,000 houses required within the next 20 years could be achieved within Glasgow’s existing boundaries, leaving 60,000 houses to be built outside the city.
Inevitably this required urgent consideration of overspills as part of their plan. In March 1953 Glasgow switched from trying to block the first new town (East Kilbride) to encouraging the building of Cumbernauld and arrangements with towns all over Scotland to take Glasgow's overspill population.
(Luckily, the Bruce Plan - and its proposals to knock down Glasgow School of Art, the City Chambers, Central Station and more - did not go ahead.)
By August 1953 Glasgow received approaches from potential receiving authorities regarding the possibility of provision being made in their areas for the reception of overspill of population and industry from Glasgow. These spread across Scotland and I was amazed on visiting friends in Haddington to discover a Glasgow overspill estate there - and sad that it still was identified as such.
READ NEXT:
-
This Glasgow building is one reason city can double for New York in the movies
-
Story of Glasgow shipyard which built 750 vessels on the Clyde
-
Diary reveals what it was like to do this 'lost' occupation in Glasgow
A more local overspill area was Kirkintilloch. In 1957 it decided to go ahead with a proposed pilot scheme for the erection of about 300 houses, provided that a satisfactory overspill agreement could be concluded with Glasgow and new industry introduced into the Burgh.
Negotiations commenced quickly with Messrs Archibald Low and Sons Ltd, of Partick, to transfer their engineering works to Kirkintilloch, where more than 100 men would be employed.
Simultaneously they earmarked a site at Newdyke for 150 houses to be erected by the Scottish Special Housing Association and 96 by Kirkintilloch Town Council.
Messrs Low transferred their plant from Partick to Kirkintilloch during the summer of 1959. Braby and Co Ltd, the Springburn steel manufacturing firm, proposed to erect a substantial factory at Old Mill Park, Kirkintilloch.
Encouraged by this proposal, Kirkintilloch decided to proceed with a New Town Development Scheme for 600 more overspill tenants. Disappointingly, Braby’s factory was never built, although the Town Council managed to attract some smaller industrial concerns to the Old Mill Park site.
In general, the industrial overspill failed to keep pace with the housing overspill. Many occupants of new houses at Kirkintilloch found it necessary to travel out of the town for work.
These and many Glaswegians left the city to start new lives in one of the many Glasgow overspill schemes which sprang up across Scotland.
Share