Exclusive

Why Glasgow's Harbour Tunnel project was doomed from the start

A vehicular ferry with the rotunda in the background, in 1910 <i>(Image: Glasgow City Archives)</i>
A vehicular ferry with the rotunda in the background, in 1910 (Image: Glasgow City Archives)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

In 1980, Strathclyde Regional Council announced that Glasgow’s 85-year-old Harbour Tunnel would close.

Reactions to the announcement were mixed. One Renfrewshire mother, who had initially reflected with sadness on the loss of another part of Glasgow’s built heritage, quickly changed her mind after having visited the tunnel with her children. Her new conclusion was rather less nostalgic: “Close it up”.

Many Glaswegians nowadays don’t know of the existence of this nineteenth century under-river thoroughfare, which, long before the Clyde Tunnel, provided a means for pedestrians and vehicles to cross the Clyde.

Harbour Tunnel looking north, 1971 (Image: Glasgow City Archives)

In this week’s column from Glasgow City Archives, archivist Kate Guariento looks into the history of one of Glasgow’s most unusual “attractions”.

 

The Harbour Tunnel was born during a period of ‘tunnel mania’ in the Glasgow.

The mid-1890s saw the completion of three major tunnelling projects in the city, with the opening of the Glasgow Harbour Tunnel in 1895, followed by the Glasgow Subway and the low-level stations of Glasgow Central a year later in 1896.

The Glasgow Harbour Tunnel Act, which endowed the Harbour Tunnel Company with the powers to construct a tunnel under the Clyde, had been strenuously opposed by Glasgow Corporation and the Clyde Navigation Trust.

In their petition against the Bill, the municipal authorities argued that not only would the proposed tunnel not be of “great public benefit or convenience”, but that it would “injuriously affect the interests of the harbour.”

Harbour Tunnel rotunda with horse-drawn traffic, 1896 (Image: Glasgow City Archives)

While ultimately the Bill was successful, gaining Royal Assent in 1889, these legal wranglings marked the beginning of what would continue to be a vexed relationship between the Harbour Tunnel Company and the Clyde Navigation Trust.

Work began on the south end of the Harbour Tunnel in January 1890. It actually comprised three tunnels, with one tunnel for northbound traffic, one for traffic travelling south, and a third, shallower tunnel for pedestrians. The openings of the tunnels on each side of the river were marked by distinctive rotunda buildings, designed by Simpson and Wilson of Glasgow.

These beautiful buildings housed the steep stairs down to the pedestrian tunnel for travellers on foot, as well as an elaborate system of hydraulic lifts for horses, carts and wagons making the journey 80 feet underground.

Construction of the tunnels took five years, with the pedestrian tunnel opening to the public on July 8 1895, and the vehicular tunnels opening a week later. While there was naturally a considerable degree of curiosity and enthusiasm in the initial period following the tunnels’ opening, the project was beset by problems from the get-go.

The Harbour Tunnel Company’s biggest headache came from the Clyde Navigation Trust. The day before the opening of the tunnel, the Trust, which managed the river and operated a fleet of passenger and vehicular ferries on the Clyde, halved the fares for their ferry services, undercutting the Harbour Tunnel Company and forcing them to reduce their prices in response. A drawn-out price war with the Clyde Navigation Trust, alongside mounting mortgage and maintenance costs and disappointing foot (and hoof) fall, meant that the tunnel never turned a profit.

In 1907, after just over a decade of unprofitability, the Company made a last-ditch attempt to drag their finances into the black by requesting that the Clyde Navigation Trust return their fares to what they were prior to the opening of the tunnel. The Trust declined, and, just a few months later, the Company made the decision to close the tunnels.

The tunnels lay unused for six years, gradually filling with water. Towards the end of 1912, the Harbour Tunnel Company agreed to reopen the thoroughfare on the condition that Glasgow Corporation relieve them of their financial burden by buying the tunnels. After a trial period, the local authority agreed to purchase the infrastructure for a sum of £100,000, which the Harbour Tunnel Company reluctantly accepted. In 1925, the liquidators were called in, and the Company was finally wound up.

Under the Corporation, pedestrian traffic was made free. While the tunnels were in steady use, particularly by shipyard workers or football fans heading to Ibrox, the numbers were never very impressive. In 1943, the Master of Works gave orders for the rusting lift machinery in the rotunda buildings to be scrapped and used for the war effort, ending the use of the vehicular tunnels.

By 1980, the pedestrian tunnel was used by only around 200 people a day, leading to Strathclyde Regional Council’s decision to close it up for good. Thankfully, the Council’s plan to demolish the dilapidated rotunda buildings was not carried out, and these beautiful circular structures can still be appreciated to this day. 

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos