Two teenagers on trial for murdering a 16-year-old at Irvine beach did not have DNA on the weapon used for the fatal stabbing, a jury was told on Monday.
The 15-year-old boy and co-accused Jay Stewart, 18, are accused of killing Kayden Moy on May 17, 2025.
Cole Turley, 18, pleaded guilty to the murder before the trial started at the High Court in Glasgow.
READ NEXT:
- Mum pleaded 'please don't tell me my baby is gone', teen tells murder trial
- Teen accused of murder ‘sent message saying he’d rip Kayden’s lungs out’, court hears
- Murder trial teen said 'do you want to see a fight?' before boy stabbed, court hears
Jurors were given a second day of evidence from a forensic biologist who described items of note seized as part of the investigation into the killing.
This included a lock-back knife which the court had heard was the murder weapon.
Claire Vallance previously told the court that only Turley and Mr Moy’s DNA was found on the knife.
In cross-examination Donald Findlay KC, defending Stewart, asked what conclusion "scientifically" Miss Vallance made in regards to the "murder weapon."
READ NEXT:
- Teen ‘boasted’ about 'doing him' after fatal beach stabbing, murder trial told
- Teens 'ecstatic' after making rap about youth stabbed on beach, court hears
- Teen who murdered Kayden Moy 'acted out the stabbing on friend’s couch'
She replied: "There was no DNA attributed to Jay Stewart on this knife.
Mr Findlay: "This is consistent with Jay Stewart never having handled that knife in his life?"
Miss Vallance: "Yes."
The advocate also asked Miss Vallance if she could say whether deposits of Stewart's DNA found on an extendable baton were deposited at the same time. Mr Findlay said: "Is the answer 'I don't know'"?
Miss Vallance replied: "Yes."
READ NEXT:
- Teen on trial for Kayden Moy murder claimed he did not see stabbing, court hears
- Possilpark teen battered and dragged girl along floor by hair during train attack
- Man admits having indecent images of children as young as two
Ian Duguid KC, defending the 15-year-old, in his questioning put a scenario of the knife murder weapon being passed from the waistband of his client to Turley to commit the murder.
The advocate said: "The knife in its entirety had nothing at all which can be identified from the boy?"
Miss Vallance: "That's correct."
The teenagers accused of killing Mr Moy were also seen "cuddling" and "handshaking" after the fatal stabbing, jurors heard on Monday.
Jurors were taken through a number of CCTV and mobile clips of the entire incident in a consecutive order with 42-year-old witness detective constable Brian Hamilton.
Initial clips showed Mr Moy and friends as well as the trio arriving separately at Irvine train station.
Turley and the 15-year-old were stated to have put their hoods up after getting off the train.
The footage shows the trio meeting up with two other youths before they headed to the beach.
Various mobile phone clips of the incident previously played to the court as well as the aftermath were shown to the jury.
Previously unseen footage was then played of the trio who appeared to be running down a road near to the beach.
Jurors were told Stewart and Turley were seen to be “shaking hands.”
In a later part of the footage, prosecutor Liam Ewing KC asked the witness what he could see.
DC Hamilton replied: “One hand coming out from the 15-year-old boy and one from Turley.”
Mr Ewing: “We don’t see whether the handshake is completed?”
DC Hamilton: “No.”
In later footage, Mr Ewing asked DC Hamilton who was “cuddling.”
The witness replied: “The 15-year-old boy and Turley.”
Mr Ewing: “What is happening now?”
DC Hamilton: “It looks like Turley has his arms around the 15-year-old boy.”
As the footage went on Mr Ewing asked: “What does it look like there?”
DC Hamilton replied: “It looks like the clap of the hands.”
Donald Findlay KC, defending Stewart, put it to DC Hamilton that his client “in no way” tried to disguise himself and the witness replied: “No.”
In regard to footage of the aftermath of the incident, Mr Findlay put it to the witness that there were people closer to Mr Moy than Stewart was and he replied: “It’s possible.”
Mr Findlay referenced handshaking and asked if the best person to explain why Turley was offering a handshake would be Turley himself which DC Hamilton replied: “Yes.”
The trial had previously heard that Turley, Stewart and the 15-year-old were part of The Murray Boys gang of East Kilbride, Lanarkshire.
Mr Moy and his friends were stated to be members of the rival Himshie gang.
The trial continues before Judge Lord Scott.
Share