A woman serving life for participating in a “frenzied” knife attack alongside her then partner has failed in a bid to have her murder conviction quashed.
Stacey Balfour, 25, was ordered to serve a minimum of 16 years for her role in the death of Robert Fisher, 26, on July 23, 2023 at Maxwellton Street in Paisley.
A jury at the High Court in Glasgow heard evidence how Mr Fisher was found critically injured in a flat in the Renfrewshire town.
He died in hospital four days later.
Jurors found Balfour and her then partner Cameron Woods guilty of murder following a trial.
Prosecutors said Woods fatally stabbed Mr Fisher while Balfour was “acting in concert” with him.
Jurors initially convicted Woods of murder and convicted Balfour on the lesser charge of culpable homicide.
Trial judge Lady Hood found the verdict against Balfour to be legally incompetent - in law, if Balfour had acted in concert with Woods in a murderous attack, she could not competently be convicted of culpable homicide while he was convicted of murder.
Lady Hood then invited the jurors to reconsider their verdict on Balfour after giving them further directions in law.
This resulted in the jury convicting Balfour of murder.
At the time, Balfour’s lawyer said the most appropriate course of action, in light of the culpable homicide verdict, was to record an acquittal.
That motion was refused by Lady Hood who sent the jury back out to reconsider their verdict on Balfour after giving them further directions in law.
Lawyers for Balfour believe she suffered a miscarriage of justice.
Earlier this year, defence lawyer Thomas Ross KC addressed judges at the Court of Criminal Appeal and argued that his client should not have been convicted of murder.
He said: “It’s clear, in my submission, that when the jury returned and attempted to convict Stacey Balfour by majority of culpable homicide, then they intended it to be a final verdict.
“My starting point is that the jury intended to convict her of culpable homicide.”
However, in a written judgment published on Tuesday, appeal judges Lord Beckett, Lady Wise and Lady Carmichael upheld Balfour’s conviction for murder .
Lord Beckett, who wrote the opinion, concluded that Lady Hood followed correct legal procedures and that the jury were entitled to convict Balfour of murder on the evidence available to them.
Lord Beckett wrote: “It seems clear that the jury considered the appellant to bear joint criminal responsibility for Mr Wood’s murderous assault.
“In a situation where the purported verdict did not signal that the jury had reached a final verdict of acquittal, and the ‘verdict’ was inconsistent with her directions, the judge was entitled and, in our view, correct to invite the jury to retire and reconsider their verdict.
“There is no miscarriage of justice and the appeal against conviction is refused.”
Woods was jailed for a minimum of 18 and a half years following the conclusion of proceedings.
Jurors had earlier been told all three had been in a flat with other people in the Renfrewshire town.
During this time, a witness said Woods had been spotted with a large kitchen knife.
Meanwhile, Balfour had shown someone a small lock-back blade - attached to a set of keys - which was later used in the fatal attack.
The court heard the attack was launched after the atmosphere between the group in the flat became “volatile”.
Prosecutor Erin Campbell told the jury that it was clear “the situation escalated” and eventually led to Mr Fisher being stabbed “in what amounted to a murderous attack”.
The victim managed to stagger out of the flat with blood on his face and on his T-shirt.
A man dialled 999 as Mr Fisher groaned in the background: “I have been stabbed.”
He was taken to the Queen Elizabeth University Hospital in Glasgow, where he later died.
During the trial, the court heard Mr Fisher had five separate stab wounds and possible defensive injuries.
Ms Campbell told the jury: “If you are trying to strike someone in the head or chest then there are only two possibilities.
“Either you are deliberately trying to kill the person.
“Or you are so angry and wild in the moment, you have total disregard if the person lives or dies.”
The advocate depute told the court Mr Fisher had been subjected to a “frenzied attack”.
Woods was later stopped by police at a cycle track and found to be in possession of the murder weapon, with Mr Fisher’s blood on it.
Balfour’s KC Thomas Ross said she had previously suffered a “traumatic” incident in 2014 and had been in a “toxic relationship” before the killing.
Earlier this year, Ms Campbell also addressed the appeal court and argued that the submissions made by Mr Ross should be rejected.
She said: “The judge was correct to refuse to allow the verdict to be recorded, and to send them out again with additional directions.
“The trial judge took the correct course of action in the circumstances of this case, and there has been no miscarriage of justice.”
The judges also refused a bid to reduce the sentence given to Balfour.
READ NEXT:
-
Paisley man fled crash scene after running down man ‘thinking he’d hit a dog’
-
Beast JAILED for sending explicit pictures and videos to 'girl, 14,' on Snapchat
-
'Gee me aw the money' - Man robs petrol station leaving worker 'terrified'
-
Mum yells ‘Go Stephen’ before son savagely knifes man over parking space row
-
Teen killer who stabbed man to death outside home jailed unmasked by cops
Lord Beckett wrote: “She participated in the attack. There is no indication that she sought to restrain her co-accused. “She did nothing to seek assistance for their victim, instead removing herself from the scene along with her co-accused before attempting to run away from the police.
“Far from showing immediate remorse, she misled the police in their investigations.
“Allowing for her status as a first offender, her difficult background, that she fell within the ambit of the Sentencing Young People guideline (towards the upper end of its
scope) and the importance of her being a parent of a young child, we are not persuaded that a punishment part of 16 years for her significant role in this vicious murder, committed with her knife, and for which she showed no remorse, was excessive.
“The appeal against sentence is refused.”
Share