Exclusive

New York pizza slices at Anxious Pete's draw crowds to the Barras

11
Skip to next photo
1/1
Show caption
1/1
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

A chef who once dreamed of running his own pizza spot has turned a hidden corner of the Barras into one of Glasgow's hottest food destinations.

Since opening Anxious Pete's last August, Dennis Fisher has built a devoted following for his New York-style pizza slices, with queues regularly stretching out the door of the compact market unit.

The 34-year-old's latest venture sits alongside The Pizza Cult, his original Neapolitan pizza business, which first opened in the historic market in 2023.

Anxious Pete's Pizza Barra's MarketAnxious Pete's Pizza Barra's Market (Image: Mark F Gibson)

"I've been down here with The Pizza Cult since May 2023, so about three years," Dennis said.

"Anxious Pete's has been here since August last year."

The idea came from one question customers kept asking.

"The Pizza Cult is Neapolitan style," he explained.

"I was constantly getting asked if we did slices, but Neapolitan doesn't really work as a slice because it's so floppy.

"People don't always understand the different styles, so they'd get disappointed."

Anxious Pete's Pizza Barra's MarketDenis Fisher (Image: Mark F Gibson)

After experimenting with New York-style pizzas as specials, Dennis realised he needed a separate space and a different oven to do them properly.

When a vacant unit in the Barras became available for a third time, he finally decided to take the leap.

"This unit got offered to me a few times, and I turned it down," he said.

"Eventually, I thought, let's take it and see what happens. We decided to do New York style here so I could have both."

Anxious Pete's Pizza Barra's MarketAnxious Pete's Pizza Barra's Market (Image: Mark F Gibson)

The shop's memorable name wasn't dreamed up by a branding agency. It came from Dennis' rescue greyhound, Chilli Pete, a retired racing dog.

"We rescued him after he retired from racing when he broke his leg," Dennis said.

"They don't get treated particularly well as racing dogs and, with him, I dread to think what happened because he's so messed up.

"His name is Chilli Pete. I liked the idea of 'Anxious Pete'. It reminded me of those old Popeye cartoons. The name just stuck."

Chilli PeteChilli Pete (Image: Denis Fisher)

Inside the compact shop, customers are greeted by rows of colourful slices behind glass – New York, Sicilian, Detroit and grandma-style pizzas sitting side by side.

"We like experimenting with different styles," Dennis said.

"It's less strictly New York and more of a proper slice shop. I wanted it to feel like being a kid in a sweet shop where you come in and think, 'I'll have one of those, one of those and one of those.'"

Anxious Pete's Pizza Barra's MarketInside look at Anxious Pete's Pizza Barra's Market (Image: Mark F Gibson)

Before striking out on his own, Dennis worked as head chef at Franco Manca.

It was his girlfriend who first introduced him to the Barras, sharing childhood memories of trips there with her dad to get bootleg DVDs and second-hand furniture.

"I was expecting it not to be the nicest," he laughed.

"But when I came down, especially around London Road, there were all these traders making handmade things – crochet, hand-painted signs – just amazing people doing amazing things. I thought, this is cool. This isn't what you described."

Denis Fisher runs both Anxious Pete's and the Pizza Cult from the BarrasDenis Fisher runs both Anxious Pete's and the Pizza Cult from the Barras (Image: Mark F Gibson)

Realising there was little food on offer and no dedicated pizza trader, he saw an opportunity.

"I'd always wanted to start my own pizza business, but didn't know what it would look like. I'd thought about doing a pizza van. When I saw there wasn't much food here and no one doing pizza, I thought this would be a good spot."

Building a customer base wasn't easy.

The Pizza Cult's original pitch sits in one of the quieter corners of the market, meaning Dennis had to rely heavily on social media to bring people through the doors.

"Footfall was the big challenge," he said.

"I learned very quickly it's all about social media. You have to make people excited enough to come and find you.

"People enjoyed the hunt. Customers told me they'd spent 45 minutes wandering around the market trying to find us, discovering other stalls along the way."

Anxious Pete's Pizza Barra's MarketOne of the Detroit-style slices on offer at the pizza spot (Image: Mark F Gibson)

Those days now feel a world away.

"At weekends, as soon as we open at 12, we've usually got a queue out the door until four," Dennis said.

"We still run The Pizza Cult and this place together. Back then, it was just me making pizzas for fun. Now we've got five staff, we pay VAT – it's a completely different operation."

Despite its growing popularity, Dennis wants Anxious Pete's to remain a neighbourhood spot rather than simply a destination for food lovers.

"We have loads of regulars, and that's exactly what we want," he said.

"We want people to come in for a slice, a drink or just a chat. I make a big thing about front of house being friendly and approachable because I want it to feel homely."

Anxious Pete's Pizza Barra's MarketDenis Fisher (Image: Mark F Gibson)

Every penny the business makes is being reinvested.

"When we opened, it was really bare bones," he admitted.

"We could have done with another three months and another £30,000, but we just focused on getting the pizza right. We're slowly turning it into the place we imagined."

Expansion is already on Dennis' mind, with hopes of eventually opening a second Anxious Pete's on Glasgow's Southside.

Anxious Pete's Pizza Barra's MarketDenis Fisher (Image: Mark F Gibson)

For now, though, he's happy to be part of the Barras' food revival while helping preserve the market's unique character.

"The food side has exploded," he said.

"It feels a bit like Camden Market now. But I'd hate to lose the older traders who've been here for decades. They're what made the Barras the Barras in the first place.

"There's never a boring day here. We get incredible characters coming in and people telling us their life stories. It's a really fun place to be."

I had the pleasure of heading to the Barras to try Dennis' favourite slice for myself.

Anxious Pete's Pizza Barra's MarketDenis' favourite slice (Image: Mark F Gibson)

His recommendation is a white-base New York slice loaded with mozzarella, Tuscan sausage, aged pancetta and fresh basil, finished with a creamy tomato vodka sauce.

The secret, he says, is the dough, which ferments for at least 48 hours before baking.

The result is a crisp base with a light, airy crust that's sturdy enough to fold in true New York fashion – rich, indulgent and packed with flavour in every bite.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos