Ivan McKee has, arguably, the most difficult task of all John Swinney’s Scottish Government ministers.
As Cabinet Secretary for Public Service Reform, he has the unenviable job of devising and delivering the biggest shake up of the public sector in decades.
Not only is local government to be reformed and councils reorganised on a more regional basis, reduced in number from 32 to between 6 and 10, the health services is to be administered by just two strategic health boards, replacing the 14 territorial-based boards at present.
It will involve thousands of job losses, with unions predicting as many as 20,000 and layers of management wiped out across the country.
Ivan McKee Cabinet Secretary for public sector reform (Image: Newsquest)
Read more
Scottish union warns 20,000 public service jobs could be lost in reforms
Scottish social care providers warn reform needs fair funding to avert crisis
Bosses call for pandemic style collaboration to reform public sector
Breakthrough in Glasgow City Council pay and grading talks with Unison
Glasgow City Council could be axed under government shake -up plan
The Glasgow Times spoke to McKee as he carried out a round of meetings with unions, third sector, private firms and academics over three days at the SNP Conference last week.
McKee needs to not only get the eventual proposals through parliament but get the workforce across the sectors to buy into the reform.
We asked: “How are you going to achieve consensus and do you need it?”
McKee said: “There's different parts to it.
“There's the local government piece, there's the health board piece, there's the social care piece, then there's umpteen projects on different public body amalgamations going on."
Some work can be done with different mechanisms, some need primary legislation in Parliament others secondary legislation.
He added: "Different parts of it all need different levels of support, if that makes sense.
“Depending on what it is, there'll be different levels of consensus that are required."
He is, however, realistic that you can’t keep everybody happy.
McKee added: "Clearly, the more consensus you've got, the better. But there will be situations where, frankly, different stakeholders won't agree with each other.
“So you're not going to get everybody.”
His realism over the job in hand extends to understanding that people will want to protect their services, staff and members.
Asked if he has identified self-interest that could be an issue he said the bigger picture has to be kept in focus.
McKee said: “I mean, in the nicest possible way, it's all self-interest, isn't it?
“Because to do a job right, you're representing a sector, or you're representing that group of workers, or you're representing this part of the system or whatever.
“But the important thing, and this runs right through the culture of what we're trying to change here, is people need to be thinking about the whole system and what's best for the service users and the staff that are delivering the service."
Where the care sector sits in this new plan has been raised, but the minister said that is for another day.
McKee said: “There's always a debate about how much more could be insourced. But that's a separate debate to be honest.
“At the moment we're looking at the system, where the money goes, and in the case of social care, how you're doing your commissioning part of that, but I'm not wading in there saying I need to do more of this or whatever.”
Many people may have baulked at the scale of the task but McKee appears to be relishing the challenge, and no can accuse him of hiding away.
Last year when a junior minister, he produced a strategy on the topic, so was not surprised when John Swinney asked him to deliver this.
He said: “I’m so glad to be given the opportunity and excited about the prospect that we can do something really significant, that's really going to make a difference moving into the future.”
There won’t be a big bang style changeover when everything resets, instead the process will be gradual with the minister stating “different things are going to happen at different times”.
McKee said: “There'll be stuff happening next year on some of this. And then there's a lot of different integration going on in different public bodies."
Glasgow HSCP is currently undertaking a huge service reorganisation, called STEP forward.
McKee added: “So there'll be different things that will happen at different stages, some of it will happen next year, some of it will happen after that.
“The local government stuff we will work through a period of time and once we see the shape of the solution that we're taking forward, we'll figure out what the delivery timescales are.”
It will, he said, be evolving over the next five years. “continually looking for ways to do things better and getting into the habit of not saying this organisation's stuck doing this forever, but continually looking and saying how do we make the thing more effective.”
Like everyone, he has personal experience of the services he is looking to improve.
He said: “I don't want to make a big thing about it, but it's the reality of it.
“My dad passed away earlier in the summer.
“You can't fault the workers that were providing the services.
"You see all different parts of the system and see the workers, the staff providing the service, doing a great job.
"But you see the gaps in the way the system works, it's not joined up and everybody's doing their job.
“But if I step back and look at what should that service look like in its entirety, you can see where the things aren't joined up properly."
Share