Why explanation of Hibs' goal vs Celtic doesn't wash with ex-ref

Referee David Dickinson addresses Hibernian's Joe Newell <i>(Image: Andrew Milligan)</i>
Referee David Dickinson addresses Hibernian's Joe Newell (Image: Andrew Milligan)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

A former referee has claimed that Hibs' goal against Celtic should not have stood.

Des Roache believes the goal was scored illegally as the ball appeared to be controlled by Joe Newell's arm.

The ten-man home side equalised, but Roache reckons the numerical disadvantage should have stood due to a handball.

He said: "It’s a handball, it’s hit his t-shirt line and then it’s rolled down his arm and then it’s come off maybe just above his wrist.

"I think the fact that Joe Newell looked a wee bit sheepish after he scored, thinking what’s going to be given here, that’s handball.



"Yes, it’s hit his t-shirt line but it’s then continued down his arm and he’s then scored from it."

Roache is adamant that the goal should not have stood and that VAR should have intervened.

He continued: "I know they’ve come out and said it’s not conclusive but that is as conclusive as anything there. That’s a handball, it should never have been a goal.

"That’s a foul. And if it’s in the penalty area, which it was, it’s a penalty kick.

"It’s got to be incumbent upon VAR to get the referee involved there.

"I don’t think it did (check).

"But as soon as the ball is inside the penalty area, that’s the minute you need to have your red alert on.

"You’ve got to be aware of what’s going on."

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos